National Museum discovers fake gems in its collection

An audit into the collection of precious stones of the National Museum in Prague has revealed a disturbing fact: some of its priceless gems are no more than cheap imitations. The fakes include a 5-carat diamond and a 19-carat sapphire which was believed to be worth millions of crowns.

National Museum, photo: Vitold Muratov, CC BY-SA 3.0

The major reconstruction of the headquarters of the National Museum in Prague has revealed more than just peeling paint and cracks in the walls. An inspection of the first 400 of the museum’s 5,000 precious stones and minerals showed that not all of them are what they were believed to be. Ivo Macek is head of the museum’s precious stones department.

“What we have here is still a sapphire, but it is not a natural stone as was documented when the museum gained it for its collection in the 1970s, it was artificially created so it does not have the value we thought it did. It was acquired for 200 thousand crowns and today it would have been worth tens of millions. And what we thought to be a 5-carat diamond was in fact plain glass given a diamond cutting.”

The National Museum is now trying to ascertain how the fakes came to be part of its collection, whether it was due to lack of expertise or a scam on the part of former employees. Tracing the story is not proving easy, the diamond has been in the museum’s collection since the 1960s and the sapphire since the 1970s. The person in charge of the collection back then is already dead and although the gems were kept under lock and key from the start, it will be hard to ascertain what happened. The collection of five thousand precious stones and minerals was located at different sites and was moved on more than one occasion.

A thorough inspection is now taking place of the remaining stones in the museum’s collection and the results are not pleasing – at least half the rubies which were believed to be natural stones are also synthetic. The massive audit of artefacts underway will take until 2020 since the museum is planning to check the authenticity of all its artefacts – including musical instruments, precious metals and paintings.

Michal Stehlík|Photo: Ondřej Tomšů, Radio Prague International

While this is not the sort of news that the museum wanted to precede its reopening on the occasion of Czechoslovakia’s 100th birthday in October 2018, Michal Stehlík, the museum’s deputy director, is looking on the bright side.

“When you have a collection of 20 million artefacts then a certain fraction of that may prove to be problematic. These things happen. So we will push ahead with the audit and I think we may even organize an exhibition of fakes in this and other world museums when it is concluded in 2020.”